| Nominate Nominated! | Casey's General Store |
| Nominate Nominated! | Franco's Pizza & Trattoria |
| Nominate Nominated! | Hideaway Pizza |
| Nominate Nominated! | Hunt Brothers Pizza |
| Nominate Nominated! | Jimmy's New York Pizzeria |
| Nominate Nominated! | LA Roma's |
| Nominate Nominated! | Marco's Pizza |
| Nominate Nominated! | Mazzios Italian Eatery |
| Nominate Nominated! | Mod Pizza |
| Nominate Nominated! | Old World Pizza |
| Nominate Nominated! | Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza |
| Nominate Nominated! | Pizza Hut |
| Nominate Nominated! | Russo's New York Pizzeria |
| Nominate Nominated! | Savastano's |
| Nominate Nominated! | Uncle Vinny's New York Pizza |
| Nominate Nominated! | Zoie's Pizzeria |