| Platinum | 50's Diner |
| Gold | Hideaway Pizza |
| Silver | Waters Edge Winery and Bistro |
| Bronze | Bruno's Italian Ristorante Broken Arrow |
| Top Pick | Billy Ray's BBQ |
| Top Pick | Blue Plate Cafe |
| Top Pick | Charleston's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Main Street Tavern |
| Top Pick | Ron's Hamburgers & Chili |
| Top Pick | Sugar Llamas |