| Platinum | Smokie's BBQ |
| Gold | Billy Ray's BBQ |
| Silver | Luke's BBQ |
| Bronze | Ribcrib |
| Top Pick | Billy Sims BBQ |
| Top Pick | Oklahoma Joe's BBQ |
| Top Pick | Pretty Good At Drinking Beer BBQ |
| Top Pick | Smokin Joes BBQ |
| Top Pick | Stone Mill BBQ and Steakhouse |
| Top Pick | Stu-B-Que |