| Platinum | Stone Mill BBQ and Steakhouse |
| Gold | District Burger |
| Silver | Tastee Treat |
| Bronze | Smitty's Garage |
| Top Pick | 50s Diner |
| Top Pick | Fat Guys Burger Bar |
| Top Pick | Goldie's Patio Grill |
| Top Pick | Ron's Hamburgers & Chili |
| Top Pick | Society Burger |
| Top Pick | Whataburger |
| Braum's Ice Cream and Dairy Store |