| Platinum | Laurannae |
| Gold | Handmade |
| Silver | Not Your Grandmas Cupcakes |
| Bronze | Merritt's Bakery - South Tulsa |
| Top Pick | BA Cookie Jar |
| Top Pick | Daylight Donuts |
| Top Pick | Kupcakz Bakery |
| Top Pick | Miranda's Cake Cafe |
| Top Pick | Nana Rose's Italian Bakery |
| Top Pick | Tigers Den Donuts |